Kaylynn377's Comments (188)

View Kaylynn377's portfolio
Below are comments about Kaylynn377's artwork that have been left by teachers, family or other website visitors.
Add comment
 
So good!!!
Posted 5 years ago by Grandma
 
I love this, K!!! Great job!! Love you!
Posted 5 years ago by Grandma
 
This is really good!! Keep it up! Could get some scholarship money one if these days!!
Posted 5 years ago by Aunt Jean
 
Love your artwork, Kaylynn! You improve with every project. Keep working on one of your many gifts.
Posted 6 years ago by Aunt Janelle
 
K!!! This is BEAUTIFUL!!!!! You do such a fantastic job!!! We love you!! Grandpa and Grandma!!
Posted 6 years ago by Joyce
 
Kaylynn! I didn't comment earlier because I thought it was done by your teacher! This is more than great!! It is very good!!! Proud of you!
Posted 6 years ago by Aunt Jean
 
This is fantastic Kaylynn! We are very proud of you and your art! You are doing a great ?? job!!! Love you, Papa and Nana
Posted 6 years ago by Sandy
 
Kaylynn, this is totally different from anything you have ever done but I do love it. I can see you in both sides of the self portrait. You are doing a great job. Keep it up. Love you, Nana
Posted 6 years ago by Nana Sandy
 
Kaylynn, this is totally different from anything you have ever done but I do love it. I can see you in both sides of the self portrait. You are doing a great job. Keep it up. Love you, Nana
Posted 6 years ago by Nana Sandy
 
K, It looks like a sideways Spongebob!! Sick Spongebob at that!
Posted 6 years ago by Aunt Jean
 
K, Looks real!! Good work!!
Posted 6 years ago by Aunt Jean
 
K, I would not want to meet this guy coming down the trail!! Good work! Kep it up!
Posted 6 years ago by Aunt Jean
 
Kaylynn, Is your red salamander looking for your fish? Or are they friends? I love this guy. Love you and am very proud of you. Nana
Posted 6 years ago by Sandy
 
Kaylynn! Your fish is wonderful! I think it is larger than I would hope to catch, but, I wouldn't mind eating some of it!! Keep it up!!
Posted 6 years ago by Aunt Jean
 
Kaylynn, I love your fish and the story that goes with it. You should think about writing a chapter book with illustrations by you. Love you honey. Nana
Posted 6 years ago by Sandy
 
Kaylynn your artwork gets better and better. This Sky Scape is beautiful! Proud of you young lady. Love you Nana³
Posted 6 years ago by Sandy
 
Interesting the way you see bacteria honey. You have been studying this subject well to be able to draw it so we.
Posted 6 years ago by Nsna Sandy
 
These flowers look so real! I would love to have them setting on my table. Your art is wonderful! Keep it up.
Posted 6 years ago by Nsna Sandy
 
Kaylynn, your queen is beautiful. Your work is so great. It gets better and better in every piece of art. We are proud of you!
Posted 6 years ago by Nana Sandy
 
Kaylynn!!!! This is sooo cool!! You are a wonderful artist! Keep it up peanut!
Posted 6 years ago by Christie (Mother)
 
This is soooo cool peanut!!! You did amazing! Love your artwork! Keep it up!
Posted 6 years ago by Christie (Mother)
 
Peanut, this is a great job on plant cells. You are learning quite a bit in art and science. Keep up the great work you are doing. We are proud of you. Nana and Papa
Posted 6 years ago by Sandy
 
These balls are very realistic! You are doing a great job. Love you. Nana
Posted 6 years ago by Nana Sandy
 
This baseball bat and ball is fantastic. Love it honey. Nana
Posted 6 years ago by Nana Sandy
 
This is great. To think you made your own stamp and then did this, it is great! Love you honey. Nsna
Posted 6 years ago by Nana Sandy
 
Kaylynn, That is a pretty pattern. Looks like one that would make a nice T-shirt pattern. Keep up the good work!!
Posted 6 years ago by Aunt Jean
 
Loving your art baby!!! Keep it up!
Posted 6 years ago by Christie (Mother)
 
This is amazing!!! She looks so real and ready to rule! Keep it up peanut!! Love you to Heavens back gates!!!
Posted 7 years ago by Christie (Mother)
 
Your lettering is getting better and better!Papa and I love your art work. Keep it up. Love you honey.
Posted 7 years ago by Sany
 
Very nice!! You are doing so great!
Posted 7 years ago by Grandma
 
I love this!!! Great job!!!
Posted 7 years ago by Grandma
 
This is absolutely beautiful Kaylynn. Nana is very proud of it and you.
Posted 7 years ago
 
Wow, Kaylynn, He looks realistic!!! Good jobjob!! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 7 years ago
 
This is cool baby! Love your art!!!!!!! -- Christie
Posted 7 years ago
 
This is cool baby!!! Love your art!!!!!!! -- Christie
Posted 7 years ago
 
Kaylynn, Papa and I love your owl and your fancy cage is great. Your owl looks like he loves setting for his picture that you did and you can tell he's not going in that cage. Your artwork is fantastic. Keep up the great work. You get better and better with each piece of art. Love you honey. Nana and Papa -- Nana Sandy
Posted 7 years ago
 
I love to do etching! These are good!! Aunt jean -- Jean
Posted 7 years ago
 
Kaylynn, Your picture is really good!! It reminds me of my girl's and granddaughter's drawings of what they wanted their models to look like. Keep it up!! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 7 years ago
 
This picture is really cool! I love the way you have drawn it so it looks likes a cat's paw and also like the cat's face. You are doing an excellent job. I love you and am very proud of your artwork! -- Nana Sandy
Posted 7 years ago
 
I am loving your artistic side! You have a wonderful gift my love. Keep it up kiddo! Love you peanut! -- Christie
Posted 7 years ago
 
Kaylynn, It looks like you free the same girl upside down and frowning. Its that how she is hiding?? Cute!! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 7 years ago
 
This is a fantastically great drawing on Harry Potter. Recognized him immediately! You're doing great work Peanut. We're proud of you and your work. -- Nana Sandy
Posted 7 years ago
 
You are doing amazing peanut!!! I need to remind you to bring your drawings from home to she your teacher!!! Love you very much! Mom -- Christie
Posted 7 years ago
 
Nana and Papa looks this picture of a the bubblegum machines. They look very real. Love you Pumpkin. Nana Sandy -- Sany
Posted 7 years ago
 
I cannot remember what kind of art work this is, but it looks like Yukon use crayon and then painted over the crayon. I like it! I have dove that with crayon and India ink. Keep up the good work! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 7 years ago
 
This is so beautiful!!! You did a great job! -- Grandma Joyce
Posted 8 years ago
 
Kaylynn, I love birch trees. They remind me of the area in Michigan where my grandparents lived!! Thank you for sharing. Merry Christmas to you!! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 8 years ago
 
WOW! This is amazing Pumpkin! Papa and I are very proud of you and your work. This is unique and beautiful. Love you honey. Nana and Papa -- Sany
Posted 8 years ago
 
Love you are work baby!!! You are doing wonderful!!! Keep it up peanut!! -- Christie
Posted 8 years ago
 
NICE JOB!!!!!! -- Aunt Jean
Posted 8 years ago
 
Kaylynn...This looks like a wonderful sculptured piece of fudge candy!! Delicious!! Keep up the good work! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 8 years ago
 
VERY good, Kaylynn!! I know what it is...easy! -- Aunt Jean
Posted 8 years ago
 
This is wonderful, Kaylynn. It reminds me of the area we live in with all the Native American work. Great jobQ! -- Nana Sandy
Posted 8 years ago
 
Kaylynn, this is really neat, especially for Halloween! Nana and Papa love it. Keep up the great work. -- Nana Sandy
Posted 8 years ago
 
I like thus a lot! Is it a piccture of a pot or did you do it in clay? I U Can Not find the description.. Love you! -- Jean
Posted 8 years ago
 
Spooky!!! Is this air brushed? It almost looks like glass works. Keep up your good work. Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 8 years ago
 
Kaylynn, This is great!! I really like it! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 8 years ago
 
Kaylynn, That is a great shelf decoration! Good color and I love pinch post! Keep it up! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 8 years ago
 
Bob this is so cool!! Loving it!! Needs to go on the entertainment center with the rest of the pots! Keep it up peanut! Love you! -- Christie
Posted 8 years ago
 
Hey love you are doing great with your art! I love you very much and hope you have a wonderful day. I know I got after you this morning but it’s cause I love you and want you to do wonderful in school. Love you peanut. Mom -- Christie
Posted 8 years ago
 
WOW! Your crayon looks real!! Keep up the good work@ Love you. Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 8 years ago
 
Kaylynn... That's a NICE horse. Good job!! Don't stand behind it. He might kick!! :) -- Aunt Jean
Posted 8 years ago
 
Mylanta bob!! You did a fantastic job!! You are certainly talented! Keep it up peanut! Love you! -- Christie
Posted 8 years ago
 
Cool crazy pink dragon! Love it bob! -- Christie
Posted 8 years ago
 
Love love love this hummingbird!!! Keep going peanut!! Love you! Momma -- Christie
Posted 8 years ago
 
Kaylynn, I love your hummingbird! It should get full with all the butter cup flowers around it! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 8 years ago
 
I love your hummingbird. You are becoming a great artist Kaylynn. Love you honey, Nana -- Sandy
Posted 8 years ago
 
i DO NOT KNOW IF DRAGONS ARE SUPPOSED TO BE PRETTY, BUT YOURS IS! Keep up the good work, Kaylynn!! Love you! -- Jean
Posted 8 years ago
 
Love your dragon, and she looks so friendly. Papa and I are you of your art. You're doing at great job Pumpkin. Nana Sandy -- Sandy
Posted 8 years ago
 
Love bug I love your dragon Pinkie Dinkie!! Great job peanut! Love you and keep up the fantastic work!! Love mom! -- Christie
Posted 8 years ago
 
I love your pinwheel! It has all the colors of the rainbow and a few tints of some of them. What did you use for the lollipop top? They almost appear exactly the same...i see now, they are different, GOOD JOB!! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 8 years ago
 
Love this birds baby!! Keep it up! -- Christie
Posted 8 years ago
 
Peanut!! This is way cool!!! Great job love!! -- Christie
Posted 8 years ago
 
I love your winter birds!! Great job peanut!! ?? -- Christie
Posted 9 years ago
 
K.. This looks like a very nice place mat for a western table!! I like it! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 9 years ago
 
Kaylynn, This is tremendous work!! I love cardinals in the winter time against the white snow. Keep up the good work!! Love you good! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 9 years ago
 
Kaylynn, Lovely! A charming castle! I am so glad you did not put a moat around the castle! They usually have alligators in them. If that happened, then probably Nana Sandy and I couldn't come visit! We do not like alligators, but love the castle!! And love you!! -- Jean
Posted 9 years ago
 
Nana loves your castle. It looks very real and would love to visit it with you. Love Nana Sandy -- Sany
Posted 9 years ago
 
Peanut love the painted jar! Your flutter shy is wonderful!!! Keep reaching for the stars and you will get there! You will be a great fashion designer! Love you peanut. -- Christie
Posted 9 years ago
 
This painting is absolutely wonderful Kaylynn. Nana and Papa love it! You did a great job and we're proud of you. Nana -- Nana
Posted 9 years ago
 
I really like your pinch pot!! Your cousin, Becky, made one for me many years ago in blue and green. I like them. -- Jean
Posted 9 years ago
 
Kaylynn, I really like your jar project! You have everything necessary in it.you have the proportions right, and great color! Good for you!! Keep it up! -- Jean
Posted 9 years ago
 
Awe! I love your pot peanut!!! Keep going on doing a fantastic job with art! Love you! -- Christie
Posted 9 years ago
 
This is beautiful Peanut. Nana loves it and so does Papa. You are doing a great job. Keep it up and I'll be proud to say I'm Nana of the great artist Kaylynn! Nana -- Sany
Posted 9 years ago
 
Hey, Kaylynn, You red and white checked place-mat has a green and white soccor ball coming out of it! Hahaha! This is good! Love, Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 9 years ago
 
Kaylynn, Is your animal trying to eat the cacti??I don't think I want to meet up with the animal or the cactus!! Good job!! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 9 years ago
 
Kaylynn... Mrs. Potato Head looks just like herself!! Good job!! How does her skinny legs hold her big body??!! You have her braced up quite good!! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 9 years ago
 
Kaylynn, I love your girl eating watermelon and your pottery piece. Keep up the good work.Love you!! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 9 years ago
 
I love your pottery work Kaylynn. You are doing a great job and I'm very proud of you. Love you Peanut. -- Sany
Posted 9 years ago
 
This is a great protrait picture of yourself. Nana loves the pictures you. -- Sany
Posted 9 years ago
 
You getting better and better. This is wonderful granddaughter! Papa and I are proud of you and your art! Love you! -- Sany
Posted 9 years ago
 
This picture is very pretty. Looks like a stained glass window like a rosetta! ?? -- Jean
Posted 9 years ago
 
Beautiful piece peanut!!! ?????? -- Christie
Posted 9 years ago
 
Great giraffe peanut!! You are doing fantastic!! ?? -- Christie
Posted 9 years ago
 
Peanut this is a great picture. I'm proud of how well you are doing with your art. Keep it up! Love you.Nana Sany -- Sany
Posted 9 years ago
 
Kaylynn, I am not sure which animal you have drawn but it's neat!! And a pretty color! I like the palm tree, too! -- Jean
Posted 9 years ago
 
Love your Valentine Kaylynn. You're a great artist who keeps getting better and better with each picture. Love you! -- Sany
Posted 9 years ago
 
Very good love bug!!! Keep it up! -- Christie
Posted 9 years ago
 
We love you cat Kaylynn. He's ready for whatever sport you want to play! Love your artwork. Papa and Nana -- Nana Sandy
Posted 9 years ago
 
Peanut! I love this one!! You did a fantastic job on the snow snowman and trees! I don't know who the person is but you did a great job! Love your imagination! Keep it up! -- Christie
Posted 9 years ago
 
This is a beautiful picture Kaylynn. Nana and Papa are very proud of your art andof you. Love you and continue on with your beautiful art work. -- Sany
Posted 9 years ago
 
Kaylynn, this monkey in a mug is great. We love it! Nana -- Sandy
Posted 10 years ago
 
That is pretty cute!! Loooks like a monkey in a cup... I love it! -- Christie
Posted 10 years ago
 
Great job peanut!! Hopefully it will snow so we can make some snowmen also! I love you! -- Christie
Posted 10 years ago
 
Kaylynn, Looks like your quail has laid eggs! or she has fat feet! :) Good job!! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 10 years ago
 
Kaylynn, What did kitty get into? She looks fun!! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 10 years ago
 
Kaylynn, This is not a bug or an octopus that I would want coming at me!! The colored legs would probably break off! But he is pretty! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 10 years ago
 
Modern girl with hair all different colors! I guess she couldn't make up her mind which color she liked the best! Hahaha1 Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 10 years ago
 
Kaylynn, I love water color! Fun! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 10 years ago
 
Kaylynn, This picture reminds me of the potholders I used to make when I was about your age! Pretty! Auntie Jean -- Jean
Posted 10 years ago
 
Kaylynn... I love snowmen! It looks like one rolled in the coal pile!! They are cute! Thanks for allowing me to see your art! Keep up the good work! Auntie -- Jean
Posted 10 years ago
 
This is absolutely wonderful Kaylynn. I love it. Nana -- Sany
Posted 10 years ago
 
Kaylynn! What a good job! Keep up your good work!! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 10 years ago
 
Great going Kaylynn. Papa and Nsna are proud of your work and you. -- Sany
Posted 10 years ago
 
Kaylynn, You made a very nice pinch pot pumpkin. Becky, my oldest daughter, made one in art class as well. Her's is blue. Nice job!! Love you, Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 10 years ago
 
Great job peanut!!! This is a very cute pumpkin! Love you! -- Christie
Posted 10 years ago
 
I love the kitty cat peanut!! So very well done! -- Christie
Posted 10 years ago
 
Love the witch! Your art is so wonderful love!! Keep going! -- Christie
Posted 10 years ago
 
You did a fantastic job on the Statue of Liberty! She is wonderful peanut!!! Keep it up! -- Christie
Posted 10 years ago
 
Very nice vase of flowers, Kaylynn!! They look like zinnias. I love them. -- Jean
Posted 10 years ago
 
Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 10 years ago
 
I love the vase face peanut!! You did a fantastic job and the flowers are beautiful!! Great job love! -- Christie
Posted 10 years ago
 
Great job love!!! Diamond girl is wonderful! -- Christie
Posted 10 years ago
 
Kaylynn... This rain picture is really very good!!! I hope you will continue art in 3rd grade. -- Jean
Posted 10 years ago
 
This is beautiful and looks likw you do with ypur umbrella in thd rain. Love Nana -- Nana
Posted 10 years ago
 
Hey, Kaylynn!!! Great job! People are hard to draw people!! Very good! -- Jean
Posted 10 years ago
 
Love your portrait is wonderful!!! I love you and your wonderful art! Keep it up peanut! -- Mommy
Posted 10 years ago
 
75Great job, Kaylynn! I love the nose and beady eyes!!! Aunt Kean -- Jean
Posted 10 years ago
 
Kaylynn, You would know all about hot air balloons! Yours is very pretty Keep up the good work!!! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 10 years ago
 
Kaylynn.... Great job! Keep up the good work!!! ;o) Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 10 years ago
 
I love these, punkin. Looks like you made a special pic for nana. I love you! -- Nana
Posted 10 years ago
 
This is way cool peanut!!! Good job! -- Christie
Posted 10 years ago
 
You did a wonderful job peanut!!! Love you! -- Christie
Posted 10 years ago
 
Love your kitty, Kaylynn. Love Nana -- Nana
Posted 10 years ago
 
Very very nice Kaylynn. You get better every time. Love Nana -- Nana
Posted 10 years ago
 
I love this!! You look like you are having fun flying across the sky! Love you peanut! -- Christie
Posted 10 years ago
 
Great job, Kaylynn!! You are getting better and better. -- Aunt Jean
Posted 10 years ago
 
Great nutcracker peanut!!! Love you!! -- Christie
Posted 11 years ago
 
Kaylynn, you did a great job on the nutcracker. Nana and Papa are very proud of you! -- Nana Sandy
Posted 11 years ago
 
Kaylynn, I thought right away that your picture looked like a nutcracker. Then I found out it was right. Yea!! Good job! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 11 years ago
 
Love your tree peanut!!! -- Christie
Posted 11 years ago
 
Great job, Kaylynn! I love the scarecrow! -- Jean
Posted 11 years ago
 
Hey, Kaylynn, Nice owl you made!! I l I ve the purple. :) -- Jean
Posted 11 years ago
 
Peanut!! That is wonderful!! You are growing up so fast! And your work is just fabulous! You always say your going to be an artist and I think you are on your way!! Love you! -- Christie
Posted 11 years ago
 
Papa and Nana are so proud of your owl and of you. Love you honey. -- Sandy
Posted 11 years ago
 
Kaylynn, This is cute! GOOD JOB! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 11 years ago
 
That is a super witch!! Spiders are icky!?? love you peanut!!
Posted 11 years ago
 
She looks like your little Rosie. She's beautiful. Nana's proud of you and your art work! Love you. -- Sany
Posted 11 years ago
 
You did a great job hunny!! Love your colors and how great your doing!!
Posted 11 years ago
 
Good job, Kaylynn! -- Jean
Posted 11 years ago
 
Love your chickens!!! You are doing so great with your coloring and drawing peanut!
Posted 11 years ago
 
Your imagination surprises your Nana more everyday.Love your and love your egg. -- Sany
Posted 11 years ago
 
Very pretty!!! -- Jean
Posted 11 years ago
 
Oooooo peanut!!! You did an amazing job on your butterflies!! Love you more everyday! Love mommy!
Posted 11 years ago
 
Peanut!!! You are doing great on your painting, coloring and dreaming!! You will become the artist and designer that you want to become! Love mommy
Posted 11 years ago
 
Kaylynn... This looks like good eating. Infortunately, I am not an ant! :) Just an aunt!! -- Jean
Posted 11 years ago
 
This looks like the perfect picnic for the ants. Very proud of your art. We love you, Nana and Papa -- Nana
Posted 11 years ago
 
These seahorses are wonderful. Nana is so proud of your apart work. Love you. -- Nana Sandy
Posted 11 years ago
 
Kaylynn... Your seahorses are beautiful!!! Keep up the good art work! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 11 years ago
 
Great job peanut!!!! Love all the wonderful colors!! -- Mommy
Posted 11 years ago
 
Hey monkey! Great job on your rooster!! Love it!!
Posted 11 years ago
 
Love the bug my sweet bug! Wouldn't be cool to go on that rollercoaster ride!? Love you Kaylynn. Mommy
Posted 11 years ago
 
Kaylynn... I really like your bug rollercoaster. You bug looks like she is having fun! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 11 years ago
 
Very good Kaylynn! It's Nana and Kaylynn!! -- mommy
Posted 11 years ago
 
You did a great job, honey. Papa and i are very proud of you. Love you muchly. -- Sany
Posted 11 years ago
 
So very proud of your work honey. Nana loves you?? -- Sany
Posted 11 years ago
 
Peanut you did such a wonderful job. Love you bug
Posted 11 years ago
 
You did a wonderfully great job on your weaving Peanut. Love you, nana and papa -- Nana ~ Sandy
Posted 11 years ago
 
Good job , Kaylynn! Nice pattern too!! Aunt Jean -- Jean
Posted 11 years ago
 
Sweet peanut, I love your owl!! You did a wonderful job on it!! Love you lots!! -- Christie
Posted 12 years ago
 
Kaylynn... Your little buggy animal is cute. It looks like he or she is trying to keep a secret! I won't tell him Santa is coming!! Love you... -- Aunt Jean
Posted 12 years ago
 
This is a great penguin Kaylynn. Nana and Papa are proud of the art work you do and this is great! -- Sandy
Posted 12 years ago
 
This is very cute peanut! I love how great your art work is! Keep up the great job! Mom
Posted 12 years ago
 
Wow!! A cute turkey for a young turtkey or ham! You are the best little niece!!! -- Aunt Jean
Posted 12 years ago
 
Love your turkey turkey peanut!! -- Christie
Posted 12 years ago
 
Kaylynn... I saw your new artwork. Nice goin'! Hope you are ready for a nice Thanksgiving. Is Daddy going hunting to get your turkey? HAVE A WONDERFUL HOLIDAY!!! -- Aunt Jean
Posted 12 years ago
 
What a lovely snowman! Have you had snow yet? We did but it didn't stay. -- Aunt Jean
Posted 12 years ago
 
Nana is very proud of your art. You are doing a great job. Love you. -- Nana Sandy
Posted 12 years ago
 
Great job my sweet peanut! Love you more than you know!! Mommy
Posted 12 years ago
 
I love your selfie Kaylynn! Keep up the good work! Love you and miss you. -- Jean
Posted 12 years ago
 
Beautiful Queen peanut!! You did a great job! Love ya!! -- Christie
Posted 12 years ago
 
Love your art projects honey. You're doing a great job. Love you, Nana Sandy -- Sandy
Posted 12 years ago
 
Kaylynn Your Raggedy Ann Looks like a Raggedy Ann!! Great Job!! Aunt Jean -- Aunt Jean
Posted 12 years ago
 
Great job kiddo!!! Love you bunches! -- Christie
Posted 12 years ago
 
Great job on your tea set!!! -- Christie
Posted 12 years ago
 
You are doing so good peanut! I love your art work!! -- Christie
Posted 12 years ago
 
You did an awsome job peanut!! Love you!! -- Christie
Posted 12 years ago
 
Kaylynn That is a very good job on drawing your family. We are proud of you Aunt Jean and Uncle D -- Jean
Posted 12 years ago